Despite fears over declining economic growth, a multitude of trade war scares and endless political bickering, 2019 has proven to be a terrific year for investors as the US stock market posted its highest returns since 2013. And it wasn’t just US equities; bonds, non-US stocks, gold, etc. all posted extraordinary returns at lower and lower levels of risk. Risk adjusted returns were off the charts. To quote Frank Sinatra, it was a very good year.
One year ago, Deutsche Bank, somewhat famously produced a research report indicating that of the 70 global asset classes (stocks, bonds, commodities, currencies) which DB follows, 63 posted negative returns proving that 2018 was the most challenging year for investors in the 118 year history of the study. There were very few places to hide and investor results were generally negative across the board.
What a difference a year makes.
Source: Bloomberg; 1 year thru Dec 26, 2019
In our humble opinion 2019 asset class returns were justified by a conflation of low base valuations, continued strong economic execution in the United States, global central banks which flipped the switch from tightening monetary policies to accommodative monetary policies and a diminution of fiscal policy risks, notably and most importantly US – China trade policy risk. There was also a resolution of the Brexit issue in the United Kingdom and more business-friendly fiscal policies enacted in several emerging market countries. Despite ever pending risks, market participants sniffed out this improved fundamental environment and bid up asset prices, across the economic spectrum.
So, 2019 was terrific indeed. Yet now, investors all around the world are now asking themselves, “Can this continue?”
Overall, Crow Point Partners has been optimistic on the economy and its investment implications. We have long argued that economic growth is the key and that investors need to emphasize that variable over virtually all others when evaluating investment opportunities. Going into 2020 our framework remains reasonably optimistic when we evaluate the spectrum of economic and investment variables which drive our viewpoint on the overall risk-taking environment.
Q1 2020 Key Economic and Investment Drivers
Skeptics will argue that much of the current environment is driven by a debt fueled “sugar high” which to a certain degree is true. Indeed, global debt levels have increased sharply on the back of accommodative central bank policy resulting in low to negative interest rates around the world. By which, governments, corporations and individuals can borrow money at very low levels of debt service.
The global economy, however, has benefited, over this period, as nominal global economic growth has increased commensurate with the increase in global debt through which emerging markets having seen the greatest increase in overall economic activity. Although debt levels have increased, debt service loads have fallen as lower interest rates make the debt easier to manage. As mentioned above, credit conditions and the ability to borrow at low levels of interest rates have been a meaningful positive contributor to the constructive economic backdrop which we’ve experienced. Again, growth is the key. If policies, both monetary and fiscal, lead to an environment of easy credit conditions and subsequent economic growth, investors should remain sanguine on the forward-looking outlook. If growth slows, where debt becomes more difficult to service then economies and markets will struggle.
Given our reasonably positive viewpoint on fundamental economic variables we additionally remain generally optimistic on investment opportunities, as well. We fully recognize, however, that 2019 was an extraordinary year for investors and is unlikely to repeat itself fully in 2020. Particularly for bond investors. While it is easy to become bedazzled by the 30% return in the S&P 500 this year, it has been the bond market which truly surprised investors, posting extraordinary returns, particularly in risk adjusted terms. As we have indicated in the past, it is the bond market where we believe investors need to meaningfully adjust their expectations for forward returns. In 2019 the Barclays Aggregate index posted roughly a 9% return and long maturity US Treasuries posted a 15% return. In as much as we are not forecasting a bond market “crash”, the fixed income returns which we experienced over the past twelve months are unlikely to repeat in 2020. Correspondingly, we believe investors should proceed with caution in the bond market mitigating interest rate risk and keeping bond portfolios at relatively short duration profiles. Opportunities in corporate credit related investments should outperform if economic activity remains relatively strong.
When looking at global equity markets the opportunity set remains quite disparate. US stocks remain rich on a relative basis, yet the domestic fundamental outlook is among the world’s best and the most visible. Politics will likely grab the headlines in the US this year and cause bouts of investor anxiety and volatility. Yet, in the absence of a true political shock and a dramatic change from the current constructive fiscal policy framework, the US economy will likely to continue its strong growth and investment opportunities should continue to be robust. International markets generally remain “cheap” relative to the US, but some would argue for good reason. Generally speaking, the policy mix overseas is a mishmash of tight fiscal constraint couple with robust monetary stimulus. Money is cheap but incentives are weak. Correspondingly, economic execution has been poor, particularly in developed markets. Emerging market equity markets are more fragile often plagued by extreme political or policy risk which inhibits EM equities from realizing their full potential.
Global investors have spent the better part of 10 years evaluating so called value opportunities overseas only to continue to be disappointed by the performance dispersion between US and international equities. We too continue to look for timely opportunities to allocate more monies overseas but currently remain more focused on domestic opportunities as the visibility to strong economic performance and corporate profitability are better in the US. Perhaps, a further reduction in the trade dispute between the US and China could act as a catalyst for better international market returns. We have seen some rotation to foreign markets in the fourth quarter as both Emerging Markets and other export-oriented markets and sectors have performed better. See Germany, for example. Yet, overall we believe that the investing opportunity set remains better in the US and we will continue to overweight domestic equities, particularly smaller cap companies.
One of the challenges in writing market outlook pieces is that it is very hard to be original. Between Twitter and the plethora of 24/7 pundits (legit and otherwise) virtually any investment thought is well picked over and debated long before we get around to writing about it. Having said that, there are ideas worth repeating, particularly ones which reflect the general optimism and robust opportunity set which we believe are available to those investors willing to remain amazed by the technological and productivity enhancements which we experience in our lives, every day. As such, this piece, by Andy Kessler in the Wall Street Journal encompasses our general viewpoint regarding the ingenuity and dynamism of Corporate America and is worth reading.
Maybe this is all market top speak. Yet, in the meantime we’re going with it. Life is good. Enjoy it. Be optimistic. We are.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
David Cleary, CFA is a Partner and Chief Investment Officer at Crow Point Partners
He acts as lead portfolio manager on the Crow Point Portfolio Solutions and the Crow Point Global Tactical Allocation strategies. Previously he spent 23 years at Lazard Asset Management where he held a series of senior portfolio management roles over multi asset and global fixed income strategies. He additionally served as the firm’s global head of fixed income, a $26 billion platform. Prior to Lazard, Mr. Cleary worked at UBS and IBJ Schroder, mostly in fixed income asset management roles. Mr. Cleary began working in the asset management field in 1987 upon his graduation from Cornell University, with a BS in Business Management and Applied Economics. Mr. Cleary is a CFA charterholder.
To read David Cleary's full bio or other Crow Point team members, click here.